Freestanding punching bags can be filled with high impact foam or filled with combinations of air and water so achieve the same purpose. But what is the difference if any?
1. Inflatable Bags with Air and Water Filling (PVC Materials)
Pros
-
Portability: Water filled punch bags can be very heavy when filled, for example the 3 legged one shown in all black on the right of the banner has a base of all water in the legs making it very hard to move. The free standing punch bag is much more manageable but in all cases you have to fill the whole base with water otherwise it will not stand up properly.
-
Stability. The amount of water in the base for the 3 legged bag makes this very stable punch bag.
-
Impact/Firmness: The striking areas be that air for free standing bags or water for hanging punch bags can be regulated to some extent and the PVC structure can make these bags softer on impact, which is gentler on the hands, wrists, and joints, especially for beginners or those focused on technique over power. However it is important to note that the arms on the standing punch bag need to be firm to keep their shape, so it really depends on the chosen model and the degree of firmness.
-
Affordable: These bags are generally more affordable than high-impact foam alternative because they can be packaged into smaller parcels significantly reducing sea and road freight costs.
-
Storage: Should you want to take a break from training for a while these punch bags can be deflated and stowed away in smaller packages than the impact foam alternatives.
Cons
-
Temperature changes: The air and water filled bags will loose pressure in colder weather meaning you will need to re-inflate (pictured).
-
Moving: Some models are very heavy to push into the corner.
-
Installation: The water filled ones require a hose connection, meaning that you need to be close to a tap, transporting when filled is also extremely difficult.
-
Leaks: Although very sturdy the PVC structure can be pierced with sharp objects.
Best Use
-
Beginners and Casual Users: Great for light training, practicing form, or aerobic workouts. Suitable for home use.
2. High-Impact Foam Bags with Hard Plastic Bases
Pros
-
Increased Stability: The plastic base, typically filled with sand or water, provides substantial stability, making these bags better for powerful punches and kicks without tipping.
-
Realistic Resistance: High-density foam provides a more realistic feel when striking, mimicking the resistance of a traditional heavy bag and allowing for better impact training.
-
Durable Construction: Designed for heavy use, these bags are more resistant to wear and tear than inflatable PVC bags, making them suitable for regular and intense practice.
-
Variety of Sizes and Heights: Many models come with adjustable height settings, catering to users of different sizes and training needs.
Cons
-
Storage Space: Due to the size these punch bags they can take up a lot of space when not used but can easily be pushed into a corner.
-
Higher Cost: Generally more expensive due to the quality materials, construction, storage charges and particularly the sea and road freight costs.
Best Use
-
Intermediate to Advanced Users: Suitable for users who require realistic resistance and durability for heavy-hitting practice. Ideal for both home gyms and commercial training spaces where stability and long-term use are priorities.
Summary Comparison
| Feature |
Inflatable PVC with Air & Water |
High-Impact Foam with Hard Plastic Base |
| Portability |
Low-Medium, heavy when filled |
High, easy to shift into the corner |
| Adjustable Weight |
Not possible for most models |
Yes (by adding sand/water to base) |
| Stability |
High, especially for the 3 legged model. |
High (heavy base keeps it stable) |
| Impact Feedback |
Soft for air striking target areas, hard for water areas. |
Firm (high resistance, realistic feel) |
| Durability |
Moderate to Low (susceptible to leaks or punctures) |
High (resistant to heavy use) |
| Cost |
Generally lower |
Generally higher |
| Best For |
Beginners, light training |
Intermediate/Advanced users, intense training |
Overall Recommendations
-
For Beginners or those needing a portable option: The inflatable PVC punching bags are cost-effective and easy to manage.
-
For Serious Trainees or those looking for realistic feedback and stability: The high-impact foam bags with a solid base offer durability and better performance for powerful strikes.
Personal note. Initially the air and water filled bags seem like a great idea for reducing costs and getting more bang for your buck. We have trialed these for about 6 months. The water filled punch bag is just too hard to strike. The free standing punch bags with flexible bases filled with water are so hard to move around the gym when not in use especially when on tatami. I would take the traditional high impact foam with hard plastic base designs any day.
